Xcancel and Nitter have been taken down

Nitter.net and Xcancel.com have been both taken down by the X Corp "cease and desist" letter

52 points | by madduci 2 hours ago

3 comments

  • r721 1 hour ago
    Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49437283 (1149 comments)
  • shikck200 1 hour ago
    Who TF wants to use Twitter? Its the worst echo chamber out there.
    • strus 29 minutes ago
      Sir, you are controlling the buttons you push. I.e. it's up to you who you follow and what exactly you read on Twitter - just like any other social network.

      There are news that are circulating much faster on Twitter than anywhere else (for example about war in Ukraine). There are people and companies that post only on Twitter and nowhere else (especially in tech).

      • vvillena 13 minutes ago
        > it's up to you who you follow and what exactly you read on Twitter

        The Twitter experience is a highly algorithmic feed where tweets from the people you follow are not guaranteed to be in chronological order, or even shown to you at all. The default experience also mixes it other tweets "you might be interested in", that is, things they want you to see.

        There's also the fact people could freely see tweets and follow discussion threads, that's now locked behind an account requirement.

    • phoghed 14 minutes ago
      Reddit is worse imo just because of how the site is structured and the power of mods.
    • docdeek 1 hour ago
      There’s likely some information on there that some people must want to share if services like Xcancel and Nitter exist and allow you to share it without being on X itself.
    • HarlequinHair 1 hour ago
      General sentiment might be this, but every social network (even Instagram and Facebook) can be good and productive if you change how you use them.

      If you follow specific profiles/channels/pages and just read the feeds from them as if they were news, you are removing the toxic part (mostly infinite scrolling) and getting a resourceful feature.

      If for some reason someone you need to follow is on X (twitter) only, you have to choose between losing a source or compromise with the platform.

      I personally belong to the former group (and possibly you do, too), leaving behind sources, but not everyone likes it that way ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

      • vvillena 10 minutes ago
        The platform compromise is a new thing. One of the reasons people used Twitter was its open nature, enabling its use as a bulletin board where anyone could post a message and being sure that the message link was free for anyone to see. This isn't the case anymore, as X forces people to make accounts to see messages.
      • spiderfarmer 1 hour ago
        > you have to choose between losing a source or compromise with the platform

        I thought so too. But after leaving 3 years ago it turns out: Not a single source is that important.

        Also, as the importance increases, the likelihood of seeing the same information outside that hellhole increases linearly.

      • secretsatan 1 hour ago
        But it’s still supporting a man who’s a toxic as they come and working hard to distort reality and undermine democracy, you won’t wash that toxic off.
    • alexnewman 1 hour ago
      And hacker news is a diverse pluralistic utopia
      • VCFundedGenYer 5 minutes ago
        I thought "reddit moments" were bad, I never thought there'd be something worse.
      • spiderfarmer 1 hour ago
        Whataboutisms do nothing to refute genuine criticisms.
        • phoghed 11 minutes ago
          If someone thinks Twitter is an echo chamber to the extent they can’t fathom how people tolerate it (and it isn’t just an appeal for easy upvotes), but they happily post on HN, they’ll be able to clear up their initial confusion with a bit of self reflection.
        • mieses 42 minutes ago
          what about throwing stones in glass houses now?
    • Tepix 1 hour ago
      Some AI bros refuse to leave
      • spiderfarmer 1 hour ago
        If someone is still on twitter I'm just going to assume their morals align with those of Musk.

        And then I avoid them.

        • strus 27 minutes ago
          > And then I avoid them.

          Hacker News and basically everyone from YC have an official profile on Twitter: https://x.com/hackernews

        • mieses 39 minutes ago
          your vanity is interesting. not so much your comment.
  • himata4113 1 hour ago
    urgh, there goes my automatic redirect... any alternatives?

    Although, I don't see how this will hold up in court as they're pretty much an archive-like site hosting UGC.