Ask HN: I'd like to request Microsoft open source Windows XP

Please

8 points | by fosco 1 day ago

11 comments

  • runjake 16 minutes ago
    There's been some side tables mention of this from some Microsoft staff.

    Long story short: it's been discussed internally, as a gesture of good will, but they can't, due to intellectual property reasons. Further, there's no good incentive (other than ephemeral good will) for Microsoft to do so, even if they solved the IP problem.

    Regardless, there are substantial source code leaks of Windows 2000, XP, and Server 2003, if you know where to look.

  • bruce511 1 day ago
    I guess I have two thoughts that spring to mind regarding this;

    A) why?

    B) they can't. Because XP is not like some notepad app someone wrote. Rather it is a collection of software, a lot of it owned by not-microsoft and licensed to them. And that's before we talk about the security implications to existing systems still running XP.

    Thirdly, what possible benefit could they get for doing this? I can see plenty of down-sides, including some very large potential economic and legal downsides. But I can't think of an upside.

    • giantg2 1 day ago
      "And that's before we talk about the security implications to existing systems still running XP."

      And subsequent systems still using some of that code

  • Panzerschrek 1 day ago
    https://github.com/DeDf/winxp_source

    Knowing that Github is owned by Microsoft, they probably are fine with it.

  • Kwpolska 1 day ago
    Windows is continuously developed, and many parts of it changed very little between XP and 11. Not going to happen.
  • yonatan8070 12 hours ago
    And I'd like to request 5 billion dollars be transferred to my account
  • d3Xt3r 1 day ago
    ReactOS already exists and targets the API level as XP. You can even install the same Luna theme that XP used to make it look like XP.
  • efren6 1 day ago
    Download any windows installtion on The internet
  • rvz 1 day ago
    Lets say that I am Microsoft:

    Why?

  • meltyness 1 day ago
    ... this leaked 6 years ago?
  • rbmm 1 day ago
    [flagged]
  • mirmor23 1 day ago
    [dead]