20 comments

  • doodlebugging 15 hours ago
    In the last photo of the article you can see the lower part of the tile which must've been exposed to the weather.

    My eyes may deceive me but I seem to see non-random patterns on the lower half that look like they could also be cursive writing. I wonder whether someone could image the tile with lidar or a scanner or maybe do a sonic density scan across the surface to see whether anything pops out.

    • ajb 11 hours ago
      Maybe, but given it's in one piece I'm not sure that writing off the same depth would have weathered of without leaving obvious signs of flaking or something. It also seems quite deliberate that the author has used only the half that would be concealed by the next row of tiles, thus allowing it to be used without any issues.
      • doodlebugging 9 hours ago
        I agree. If there was an indication of writing below it I suspect that they would've already noted that and attempted a reconstruction. If it were my tile I know I would. Even something as simple as a pencil rubbing would help illuminate any other scribbles.

        With the resolution of the photos in the article and the fact that it is on the back side of the tile with a line clearly drawn across the tile as if to mark the end of the message it is unlikely to be more text. It just looks non-randomly patterned in that photo view.

      • pseudohadamard 30 minutes ago
        I believe the rest of the writing, now worn off, was some rambling complaint about the quality of copper ingots.
  • verytrivial 10 hours ago
    This seemed more like a retirement gift to me than anything else.
    • nly 7 hours ago
      This makes sense to me too. Perhaps it was the very last tile this retiring worker laid and this was a symbolic gesture
  • tacostakohashi 17 hours ago
    This reminds me of my high school woodworking teacher, who would tend to write late notes for other teachers on pieces of wood whenever we didn't finish class on time.
    • netsharc 10 hours ago
      Handwritten notes are usually written on pieces of wood.

      But his must be 20000 gr/m² paper...

  • dieselgate 15 hours ago
    It might be impossible to determine but wonder if it was a joke, written by another coworker or by the “dismissed”. Mostly find it odd the writing was done before the tile was cured. Anyway cool stuff. Reminds me of deciphering Roman graffiti a bit.
    • InsideOutSanta 14 hours ago
      Yeah, I had the same thought. "Ya fired" jokes are pretty common, I doubt it was much different 200 years ago, and actually dismissing somebody by carving into a roof tile seems extremely odd.
    • torben-friis 12 hours ago
      Maybe leaning on it to write? as in, pressing through paper into the half done tile?
    • lostlogin 15 hours ago
      > Deciphering Roman graffiti

      Life of Brian had pointers on Roman graffiti

      https://youtu.be/M3gNdGHsEIk

    • dofm 6 hours ago
      Writing on the tile, firing/baking it, and then leaving it in the stack for the recipient to see as he lays the roof, is exactly the kind of sneaky passive-aggressiveness that made Britain great.
  • cucumber3732842 16 hours ago
    Anywhere wood shingles/shakes are used for siding they're commonly used as scratch pads for record keeping. If the writing on them is no longer needed and they're the right size and close at hand they get installed. There are plenty of last month's time punches and yesterday's materials lists on people's houses.
  • SquibblesRedux 14 hours ago
    Perhaps the tile was used as a flat writing surface. A note may have been written on a piece of paper that was on top of the tile at the time.
    • ajb 11 hours ago
      I doubt it. You might use a fired tile as a writing surface, but an unfired one would just make a mess of the paper. And you wouldn't get lines this clear, the pen wouldn't be able to scrape through the top layer the way this has.
  • danielsoto317 11 hours ago
    I always wondered if there was a legal way to gain money with random discoveries like this, I guess just publicity for yourself or your business.
  • wolfi1 17 hours ago
    how high was the rate of illiteracy then? I' guessing it was still high at that point in time, which makes you think why it was written out in the first place.
    • post-it 16 hours ago
      1820s literacy rate in England was around 50%, though significantly higher for men.
      • sowbug 15 hours ago
        The writing on the tile is surprisingly neat and legible, especially considering the medium.

        Perhaps messy handwriting back then was less common, on the theory that either you knew how to write neatly, or you didn't know how to write at all.

        • b112 13 hours ago
          You had to write slower with a steel quill pen, I'd think. Dipping in ink pot, etc.
        • dsign 11 hours ago
          That was the first thing that jumped to my eyes. When I was at school, good calligraphy was a serious matter, but despite be best coordinated attempts of parents and teachers, none of us got to the level of perfection on that tile. So I'm go to go in a limb and say "old teaching method involving something unpleasant colliding with you at spanking speed" was how they did it.
  • indrex 21 hours ago
    Blue tile, pink slip.
  • zkmon 21 hours ago
    What's the purpose? Is it for communicating? or a signed document?

    Maybe the clay composition, the process of firing it and the final product serve as the signature of the company? Also tile can't be burnt while paper can be. Interesting idea.

    • cloudbonsai 17 hours ago
      It seems that 19th-century tile makers sometimes used clay tiles as memo pads. Cawarden Reclaim (who found that dismissal notice) stumbled upon another tile that contains an order list:

          This is an old handmade pan tile, made on 21st July 1802. [...] Reading the information, it seems that this is an order list for the maker. With no paper and pen to hand, the words were jotted down on a freshly formed clay tile, which was waiting to be dried out and fired. This tile was fired, used on a roof, and remained in place for approximately 220 years. 
      
      https://cawardenreclaim.co.uk/reclaimed-building-witness-to-...

      I imagine that it was like writing a dismissal note on the white board after a heated office argument.

    • cyberax 20 hours ago
      Perhaps it was a joke?
      • Oarch 20 hours ago
        A very British joke!
      • tag2103 16 hours ago
        Exactly what I was thinking - this looks like Thomas jabbing at John with an easter egg while he's up on a roof.
    • fodkodrasz 20 hours ago
      Why do you overthink it? (The article also seems to mystify it a bit): Possibly put a paper on a drying work item and scribed it on paper, and it got imprinted through the paper.
      • mitchdoogle 15 hours ago
        Definitely not. Writing on clay is not something that happens on accident. It requires some effort to impress into the clay and to make it legible.
        • compiler-guy 11 hours ago
          Including the fact that impressions from paper over clay are quite different from the sharp inscriptions here.
    • bryanrasmussen 20 hours ago
      It's amusing to think this was that company's loser boss version of firing by voicemail. New load of tile, you put all the tile on the roof, hey there's one extra, hey there's writing on it, aw what the hell!!?
      • bonesss 20 hours ago
        I'm reminded of the Kids in the Hall sketch where a boss calls his underling in for a superficially normal work meeting, puts his feet up on the desk, and "You're" "Fired" is written on the bottom of his shoes, sending hints until the employee quits.

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PJtBaj5dXfU

  • mjlee 20 hours ago
    I do wonder if British roofers in the 19th century had a similar sense of humour to British roofers today.

    "Psst, pass this tile up to that useless so and so John..." or "Hey, John, there's one tile left over, you can have it."

  • jareklupinski 21 hours ago
    > Once the inscription had been made, the clay was fired to create a finished roof tile and was then put to its intended use.

    fun fact: this is the origin of being 'let go' coming to be known as "getting fired"

    • yorwba 21 hours ago
      • jareklupinski 20 hours ago
        it seems to agree haha:

        > The sense of "sack, dismiss from employment" is recorded by 1877 (with out; 1879 alone) in American English.

        > Research had found a firm called Thomas Austin Brick & Tile Makers, based at Clay Hills, Stoke-on-Trent in 1820

        • yorwba 20 hours ago
          Thomas Austin in 1820 "discharged" the employee. And Stoke-on-Trent is in Britain.
          • pseudohadamard 25 minutes ago
            The British in India were also in the practice of discharging former employees, so they were fired too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowing_from_a_gun
          • layer8 20 hours ago
            Maybe he was really an electrician.
            • gpvos 18 hours ago
              Probably the first one then, electricity was still in the research stage at that time.
              • smelendez 18 hours ago
                The parent comment was a pun on discharge but incidentally Ben Franklin is often called the first electrician and credited with coining the term.
          • jareklupinski 20 hours ago
            its a long way across the pond, and you know how stories go when they travel :)
  • seanhunter 16 hours ago
    The tile next to it has got a 200-year-old offer of "generous" severance that is conditional on non-disclosure, non-disparagement, a waiver of all claims and an agreement to binding arbitration in the case of disputes.
  • layer8 20 hours ago
    > The fact that someone went to the trouble of writing that out on the back of clay before it was fired, and then firing the tile

    Not to mention firing John Lewis. It does have some consistency to it.

    • seanhunter 16 hours ago
      Every door that closes another one opens. Nowdays John Lewis is famous for home furnishings and heartwarming Christmas adverts.
  • julianlam 15 hours ago
    > "The fact that someone went to the trouble of writing that out on the back of clay before it was fired, and then firing the tile and using it for the purpose it was designed for," Giles added.

    This makes my brain hurt. The fact that some did that..... and?!

  • Aardwolf 18 hours ago
    They fired the clay to fire someone
    • donkey_brains 18 hours ago
      “Hey John, what do you and this tile have in common?”

      “What, boss?”

      “You’re both about to be fired”

  • reactordev 18 hours ago
    “To whom it may concern,

    After thus performing one’s duties with this tile, report to E. Booker for reeducation.”

    This is what I immediately thought of, some dystopian metaverse where a roofer gets sacked…

    The story is less dystopian and pale.

  • luxiedge 14 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • LoganDark 21 hours ago
    I miss the days when people would bring their animals on the job <3