Whoa... I didn't even know these existed. This is linked from that page and is a pretty cool example of what it takes to make these: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWQ0591PAxM. It's cool to see the Nintendo games are still being developed! I was 8yo when the NES came out and my mom saved up all her waitress money and bought me one that Christmas.
Basically all 8- and 16-bit consoles, as well as some later ones (such as the Game Boy Advance, Nintendo DS and more recently the N64), have very active homebrew scenes at this point. There are even no-code options for some platforms [1] that have proven to be remarkably popular, to the point even McDonald's promotional game "Grimace's Birthday" was made in GB Studio and released in emulated form. The ease of manufacturing new PCBs and cartridges using modern parts has also led to a market for physical commercial homebrew releases, both through publishers and directly from developers.
Unfortunately, like many other hobby programming niches, most homebrew communities are currently dealing with the recent influx of low-effort vibe coded games that completely defeat the point of learning to work and be creative with limited hardware. Some started adopting strict no-AI stances, which is refreshing to see when seemingly every other community is going the other way; so far my own released work (mainly on the original PlayStation) is completely free of LLM contributions and I'd like to keep it that way for as long as I can.
I've wanted to get into NES homebrewing for years but found it difficult to get started. Eventually I vibe-coded a language specifically designed to build NES games, but then fell down the rabbithole of designing that language and the compiler, instead of building games. Typical.
I was able to produce a few (very) "low effort vibe-coded games that completely defeat the point of learning to work and be creative with limited hardware", but along the way I was still able to learn how to build a compiler to be creative with limited hardware for me. And that was fun.
I'll never make anything 1/1000th as impressive as the games passionate hobbyists have made over the years, and I don't think we're even building the same thing, conceptually. For me, vibe-coding the game (and the language, and the compiler) is the game itself.
My favorite thing to come out of it is https://imjasonh.github.io/playground/nes-player/?rom=subway which is a RCR clone set on the NYC subway, complete with realistic routes, schedules and transfers. There's no "point" to it really, just go from place to place punching dudes.
But that's the thing: the things made with genAI are mostly interesting to the prompter only. Everyone is making custom one-off software that has one developer and an install base of one.
I took a glance at your game and Kunio fighting endless Kunio clones looks boring to me. I guess the realistic NYC subway angle might be interesting but it's not obviously an interesting game mechanic.
Vibe all you want, but don't expect others to be as enthusiastic of your own vibe as you are yourself.
You can call it a purity test as much as you want. It doesn't change the fact that a ban is one of the only viable tools these small craft communities have to prevent their own disintegration. Many try more lenient policies first that rely on the honor system, and then move to a ban when it turns out LLMs and their operators can violate honor systems at an industrial scale.
I love the NES — probably my favorite console! I still enjoy playing the original games today on occasion.
I have a modest (curated) collection of about 60 games, but most are what I would consider some of the best titles for the system: Dragon Warrior 1-4, Mega Man 1-6, SMB 1-3, both Zeldas, Castlevania 1-3, Final Fantasy, Destiny of an Emperor, Guardian Legend, Faxanadu, Duck Tales — just to name a few of my favorites.
Just the other day I was thinking to myself that I should look to see what homebrew/modern third titles are out there an worth playing.
Back when the NES mini went on sale and it was easy to add ROMs, I added a few homebrew games that were floating around at the time.
'Princess Peach in the Mushroom Kingdom' was the most acclaimed homebrew option, essentially a re-skin and level re-design of SMB3 with SMB2 Peach as the protagonist. So the solid gameplay remained, and the levels were HARD. Great work by the dev, and obviously a labor of love.
I'm thrilled to see that so many new and re-worked titles are out there, and even for sale. Great work by the community!
This is awesome! Tooling is often an underappreciated aspect of development. Better tooling allows for higher quality output at lower effort, and the tooling today for developing against older platforms would cause developers past to drool.
If you're curious about making NES games, there's literally never been a better time to start than today. Unless you count tomorrow...
My favourite example of this effect is the large expansion to Morrowind that is Tamriel Rebuilt. Their quality standards in the last few releases have been so high, the base game wouldn't pass them anymore. Yet their release tempo is increasing. Much of this is due to big effort by its loving developers, but some of it also comes down to improved tooling that just didn't exist a couple of decades ago.
There's a similar story around the old PDP computers. People with modern computers as tooling have managed to coax old PDP computers into doing things they always could, but which it was insurmountable to get them to do without the modern tooling.
I guess what I want to say by this diversion is this: if you don't know what project to take on in your spare time, develop tooling for an old platform you like. You'll enable others to make things we couldn't even dream of before.
It’s like a modern take on Catrap, but for the NES. I believe the name might be a nod to Fire ‘n Ice, another great classic NES game in that genre.
Highly recommend it if you’re into puzzle games. I’d say that in retrospect, this is the game that is responsible for starting my interest in retro-emulation.
I backed the Lizard Kickstarter - one of the best i ever did, for Brad’s updates. I’m not going to ever make an NES game but fascinating to read about how the limitations of the hardware influence game decisions or creative hacks. I told him he could make a book out of those.
Due to various reasons (accessibility of the hardware, feasibility of solo development or with a small team), most other consoles do not have such an active scene. There are people making games for other consoles, but not in such abundance as the NES.
An exception is the Game Boy and Game Boy colour. There GBStudio has facilitated a similar wealth of games. I personally don't know that scene very well, but I keep seeing it grow from the periphery.
I didn't include it in the list because it's a pretty short game and I found the gameplay rather shallow. It's almost just a short little joke. It's not bad, just rather brief.
The Jane Austen game has much more depth. It's genuinely a good game!
A hilarious detail in the game Estique is how its English manual is deliberately poorly "translated", and in the game itself, cut scenes are slightly censored in the English version just like Nintendo used to do it in the 1980s.
The game Tunic is a wonderful homage to the original Zelda and NES games (and a great game unto itself). Part of it is that you discover aspects of the gameplay through piecing together an in-game NES-style manual and deciphering the scribbled notes on it.
Back in the 90's, buying such a cartridge was a big decision, since a single one would cost the allowance for several months. And with no Internet and YouTube to run a search for "Haunted Haloween 85 NES", the only criteria for evaluating such a game in the physical flea market was the poster on the cartridge. Which, unlike the OPs which at least seem to pose a resemblance to the actual game, it had almost nothing to do with how the game will look.
Consequently I almost never got the good games and was utter disappointed after trying them. Fortunately there were neighbors who also bought and we exchanged cartridges, and so I found the best game I ever remember playing on such a console, Mighty Final Fight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoUPvwCcUo8
I knew about the abundance of Famiclones, but I never knew about the Terminator 2!
Do you know if its cartridges are compatible with Dendy or Famicom cartridges? They seem similar but maybe there was an attempt to "DRM" into it own unique form factor.
99.98% these were Dendy consoles. Forall I know, these consoles arrived here by Russian way, we even called the market where you could buy these things "the Russians", even though in practice they were Moldovans ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moldova ).
But I'm not that attached to it, I bought myself a new Nintendo 8-bit NES clone and a Sega 16-bit Megadrive from Aliexpress along with cartridges which contain hundreds of games, so I'm settled.
The Sega Megadrive console from Aliexpress scratches an itch dating back to the 90s. At the time, in the "Russian" flea market there was a strange exhibit of a console which looked 100% as a Sega Megadrive, it looked like this: https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/gl4AAOSwqh5h8div/s-l1200.jpg
But worryingly, the "Russians" were telling us that it works with yellow Famicom cartridges. And there were no other cartridges for sale anyway, so no way to verify if it's some unholy bastard between NES and Sega. It cost double or triple of a regular Terminator2 and given that also cost a fortune at the time respective to my allowance money, I could only dream about buying it.
Found a few over the years on the Romanian olx ( https://www.olx.ro ) site but wasn't that curious, they are 100% pure Famicom in a Sega package (a sheep in a wolf's skin). I bought a true Sega clone from Aliexpress and the cartridge is different and the games are in another league compared to 8-bit. If I had that in the 90s, I'd have been the king of the village. We had a Street Fighter arcade in the village pub and the kids would crowd themselves along drunks to wonder at the spectacle when someone felt rich enough to pay for 2 minutes of entertainment.
In Spain tons of people bought either NES Chinese clones (even in the early PSX era in ~1997) because they were dirt cheap. Also, N in 1 cartridges were everywhere, both for the NES and the GB.
Mine came with Batman:Tas, FFIII (Secret of mana for GB), Goal! and Metroid II among others. I loved it.
Maybe the original ones where Pokémon, SML 1 and 2, Donkey Kong and a few more (the ML games were Nintendo Classics and sold for very cheap).
In the GBC era most people got originals, but even in these times tons of bootleg X in 1 games were sold too. Also, I was very lucky to buy the Cannon Fodder cartridge for 5 EUR (~$5 in 2002, second hand) for the GBC as it condensed the whole Amiga/PC game with nearly all the graphic quality.
And with Metal Gear:Ghost Babel for the GBC I didn't miss Metal Gear for the PSX at all.
>> In Spain tons of people bought either NES Chinese clones (even in the early PSX era in ~1997) because they were dirt cheap.
I'll let you know a secret. I bought my console in 1997! :)
1997 was maybe the year of peak hyperinflation in Romania, I've checked my parent's paychecks from the period and while both of them were employed in white collar (better paying) jobs, both their income converted in today's money didn't make $200. Not euro, dollars, although recently that seems to catch in parity. A monthly income for salaried parents of €150, taking care besides them and the household of me and my two brothers, so a family of 5. Therefore "dirt cheap" didn't apply here and I guess, I was fortunate for being to afford even such a console.
On a side note, around that period, my younger brother went with a school exchange in Austria. Thought of a lunch at Mcdonald's as the most luxurious thing one could experience. Today I'm paying some €10 for such a lunch and don't think about it but imagine you'd be paying 6.67% of your net income for a lunch (how much it cost relative to my parent's income in 1997). That'd be €267 in today's money for me, fuck, I ain't going even to a restaurant and paying that, I'm not a millionaire!
Unfortunately, like many other hobby programming niches, most homebrew communities are currently dealing with the recent influx of low-effort vibe coded games that completely defeat the point of learning to work and be creative with limited hardware. Some started adopting strict no-AI stances, which is refreshing to see when seemingly every other community is going the other way; so far my own released work (mainly on the original PlayStation) is completely free of LLM contributions and I'd like to keep it that way for as long as I can.
[1] https://www.gbstudio.dev
I was able to produce a few (very) "low effort vibe-coded games that completely defeat the point of learning to work and be creative with limited hardware", but along the way I was still able to learn how to build a compiler to be creative with limited hardware for me. And that was fun.
I'll never make anything 1/1000th as impressive as the games passionate hobbyists have made over the years, and I don't think we're even building the same thing, conceptually. For me, vibe-coding the game (and the language, and the compiler) is the game itself.
https://github.com/imjasonh/playground/blob/main/nescript/RE...
My favorite thing to come out of it is https://imjasonh.github.io/playground/nes-player/?rom=subway which is a RCR clone set on the NYC subway, complete with realistic routes, schedules and transfers. There's no "point" to it really, just go from place to place punching dudes.
I took a glance at your game and Kunio fighting endless Kunio clones looks boring to me. I guess the realistic NYC subway angle might be interesting but it's not obviously an interesting game mechanic.
Vibe all you want, but don't expect others to be as enthusiastic of your own vibe as you are yourself.
Purity tests are a sign that things may be crossing a line.
I love the NES — probably my favorite console! I still enjoy playing the original games today on occasion.
I have a modest (curated) collection of about 60 games, but most are what I would consider some of the best titles for the system: Dragon Warrior 1-4, Mega Man 1-6, SMB 1-3, both Zeldas, Castlevania 1-3, Final Fantasy, Destiny of an Emperor, Guardian Legend, Faxanadu, Duck Tales — just to name a few of my favorites.
Just the other day I was thinking to myself that I should look to see what homebrew/modern third titles are out there an worth playing.
So I’d say this post was actually perfect timing!
'Princess Peach in the Mushroom Kingdom' was the most acclaimed homebrew option, essentially a re-skin and level re-design of SMB3 with SMB2 Peach as the protagonist. So the solid gameplay remained, and the levels were HARD. Great work by the dev, and obviously a labor of love.
I'm thrilled to see that so many new and re-worked titles are out there, and even for sale. Great work by the community!
Curiosity got me, is it challenging to add ROMS on the NES mini today?
If you're curious about making NES games, there's literally never been a better time to start than today. Unless you count tomorrow...
My favourite example of this effect is the large expansion to Morrowind that is Tamriel Rebuilt. Their quality standards in the last few releases have been so high, the base game wouldn't pass them anymore. Yet their release tempo is increasing. Much of this is due to big effort by its loving developers, but some of it also comes down to improved tooling that just didn't exist a couple of decades ago.
There's a similar story around the old PDP computers. People with modern computers as tooling have managed to coax old PDP computers into doing things they always could, but which it was insurmountable to get them to do without the modern tooling.
I guess what I want to say by this diversion is this: if you don't know what project to take on in your spare time, develop tooling for an old platform you like. You'll enable others to make things we couldn't even dream of before.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Fantasy_VII_(NES_video_g...
And it looks like there’s even an English translation patch:
https://www.romhacking.net/translations/2369/
Little Sisyphus https://youtu.be/to0rkV_SbMA
Böbl https://youtu.be/xBfvMA3tz9k
A video game essay rpg with a lot of tongue in cheek references to 80’s culture, gaming, coding etc.
It’s like a modern take on Catrap, but for the NES. I believe the name might be a nod to Fire ‘n Ice, another great classic NES game in that genre.
Highly recommend it if you’re into puzzle games. I’d say that in retrospect, this is the game that is responsible for starting my interest in retro-emulation.
Or, if you were making a plug-and-play game device in the 2000s, it was often easy to use a clone NES SoC as a foundation.
[1] https://youtu.be/SHw763qRyJ8
At least one of these (Sam's Journey) seems to run perfectly on Retropie on a Raspberry Pi 3.
An exception is the Game Boy and Game Boy colour. There GBStudio has facilitated a similar wealth of games. I personally don't know that scene very well, but I keep seeing it grow from the periphery.
There are plenty of new homebrew games (some really impressive, like cathode quest and junk runner), but I didn't see yet a good curated list
https://www.greatgatsbygame.com/games/Gatsby.nes
I didn't include it in the list because it's a pretty short game and I found the gameplay rather shallow. It's almost just a short little joke. It's not bad, just rather brief.
The Jane Austen game has much more depth. It's genuinely a good game!
Back in the 90's, NES clones were all the rage in Eastern Europe:
With ludicrous names like "Gold Leopard King" https://www.reddit.com/r/crappyoffbrands/comments/1ekwzx5/go...
Or mimicking a Sega Genesis package and console look, this is the one that was most popular in Romania and I had one too : https://gadget.ro/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/terminator2.jpg
There's still a ton of old cartridges for it on sale on the flea market: https://www.olx.ro/d/oferta/jocuri-clona-nes-dischete-casete...
Back in the 90's, buying such a cartridge was a big decision, since a single one would cost the allowance for several months. And with no Internet and YouTube to run a search for "Haunted Haloween 85 NES", the only criteria for evaluating such a game in the physical flea market was the poster on the cartridge. Which, unlike the OPs which at least seem to pose a resemblance to the actual game, it had almost nothing to do with how the game will look.
Consequently I almost never got the good games and was utter disappointed after trying them. Fortunately there were neighbors who also bought and we exchanged cartridges, and so I found the best game I ever remember playing on such a console, Mighty Final Fight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoUPvwCcUo8
Do you know if its cartridges are compatible with Dendy or Famicom cartridges? They seem similar but maybe there was an attempt to "DRM" into it own unique form factor.
I still have my Terminator2 console at home but doesn't power up anymore, otherwise it could fetch some 150 EUR on the flea market: https://www.olx.ro/d/oferta/consola-retro-terminator-2-endin...
But I'm not that attached to it, I bought myself a new Nintendo 8-bit NES clone and a Sega 16-bit Megadrive from Aliexpress along with cartridges which contain hundreds of games, so I'm settled.
The Sega Megadrive console from Aliexpress scratches an itch dating back to the 90s. At the time, in the "Russian" flea market there was a strange exhibit of a console which looked 100% as a Sega Megadrive, it looked like this: https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/gl4AAOSwqh5h8div/s-l1200.jpg
But worryingly, the "Russians" were telling us that it works with yellow Famicom cartridges. And there were no other cartridges for sale anyway, so no way to verify if it's some unholy bastard between NES and Sega. It cost double or triple of a regular Terminator2 and given that also cost a fortune at the time respective to my allowance money, I could only dream about buying it.
Found a few over the years on the Romanian olx ( https://www.olx.ro ) site but wasn't that curious, they are 100% pure Famicom in a Sega package (a sheep in a wolf's skin). I bought a true Sega clone from Aliexpress and the cartridge is different and the games are in another league compared to 8-bit. If I had that in the 90s, I'd have been the king of the village. We had a Street Fighter arcade in the village pub and the kids would crowd themselves along drunks to wonder at the spectacle when someone felt rich enough to pay for 2 minutes of entertainment.
Maybe the original ones where Pokémon, SML 1 and 2, Donkey Kong and a few more (the ML games were Nintendo Classics and sold for very cheap). In the GBC era most people got originals, but even in these times tons of bootleg X in 1 games were sold too. Also, I was very lucky to buy the Cannon Fodder cartridge for 5 EUR (~$5 in 2002, second hand) for the GBC as it condensed the whole Amiga/PC game with nearly all the graphic quality. And with Metal Gear:Ghost Babel for the GBC I didn't miss Metal Gear for the PSX at all.
I'll let you know a secret. I bought my console in 1997! :)
1997 was maybe the year of peak hyperinflation in Romania, I've checked my parent's paychecks from the period and while both of them were employed in white collar (better paying) jobs, both their income converted in today's money didn't make $200. Not euro, dollars, although recently that seems to catch in parity. A monthly income for salaried parents of €150, taking care besides them and the household of me and my two brothers, so a family of 5. Therefore "dirt cheap" didn't apply here and I guess, I was fortunate for being to afford even such a console.
On a side note, around that period, my younger brother went with a school exchange in Austria. Thought of a lunch at Mcdonald's as the most luxurious thing one could experience. Today I'm paying some €10 for such a lunch and don't think about it but imagine you'd be paying 6.67% of your net income for a lunch (how much it cost relative to my parent's income in 1997). That'd be €267 in today's money for me, fuck, I ain't going even to a restaurant and paying that, I'm not a millionaire!